Here's a thread to capture all of the reviews, good, bad and indifferent for the 'finale': I'll get us started with the review from Forbes. They captured a lot of the issues I had with the episode... 'The Walking Dead' Season 6 Finale Review: Negan And His Bat Well, it looks like we’ll have to wait a few months to find out exactly who Negan killed with his bat, Lucille. I held out a grim sort of hope that we’d learn who gets killed tonight, rather than have to wait until Season 7, but my hopes were dashed. Maybe “dashed” isn’t the right metaphor for this occasion. Somebody, after all, met the receiving end of a barbwire-wrapped baseball bat. We didn’t see who—we didn’t even see the murder. We just heard it happening. Oh brother. I’m not surprised, and at the same time I’m still baffled that the showrunners could pull a move this silly. Anyways, we know it wasn’t Carl. Negan orders his men to cut out Carl’s eye if anyone attempts to stop his beating. We also know it wasn’t Rick, since Negan ordered the eye in question to be fed to Rick should this take place. I also suspect it wasn’t Glenn, since he was on the end, and it looked like Negan picked someone in the center, though I can’t be sure of that. My guess is that it wasn’t Glenn, but it still could be. Whatever the case, one of the group was killed tonight. And you can be damn well certain that millions of viewers will tune in for the Season 7 premiere to find out who that is. Read the rest here.